2026 November Advocacy Updates

Brook Street, Providence: The four historic homes located at 277, 281-283, 287 and 291 Brook Street were included on Brown University’s Institutional Master Plan Amendment presented to the Providence City Planning Commission (CPC) on Tuesday. Click here to watch the full meeting. The amendment on page 9 in the Institutional Master Plan proposes to restore 287 and 291 Brook St. built in 1886 by Alexander Gorham, a Black real estate developer.
During Brown’s presentation, it was proposed that 287 and 291 Brook St. will be lifted, moved back from the street and a new foundation will be dug to create a wider sidewalk in front. Once restored, it is planned that they will be used as residential housing and/or rentals.
However, 277 and 281-283 Brook St will be made available for free to buyers willing, qualified, and able to move them to new locations. If the efforts to move 277 and 281-283 Brook St are unsuccessful, both will be offered for architectural salvage prior to demolition. It was stated that they will be made available for sale to the community with a stipend to assist in their relocation (if interested, keep an eye out for the announcement from Brown). In addition, 71-73 Charlesfield Street will be relocated from the corner of Charlesfield and Brook, eastward on Charlesfield.
A petition with over 800 signatures goes against Brown's plan and pushes for legislation to expand the Power-Cook Street local historic district, which could expand into the I-2 Educational Institutional District and provide expanded Historic District Commission oversight over the area. It is also important to note that Brown has also demolished over 150 buildings since 1945, including more than 100 homes.
After comments, Brown requested to respond. They spoke about how a shadow study was completed to assess the effects of the new building on the surrounding area. They explained that any shadows that will be cast will be on Brown’s property and not on neighboring properties, except abutters’ back yards in the winter months. They also asked what a continuance would provide besides delaying the process and explained that the master plan is vague because it is a master plan and essentially open to amendments and changes. Regarding the design of the building, officials stated that they maximized the space for which the building could fill. However, they have not included exact construction drawings.
Commission members stressed that Providence City Council should pass ordinances to help create and expand historic districts to save buildings. Also, they felt that the organizations and community groups who spoke should be more proactive than reactive to help reshape policy to save their neighborhood. Design was also discussed; they agreed that although the area is not a designated local historic district, the new building will still dramatically change the character of the neighborhood. On 277, 281-283, 287 and 291 Brook specifically, they explained that Brown should be "ashamed" of themselves to have allowed the four houses to fall in such a state of disrepair and even so, do shape the character of the surrounding neighborhood. They also felt that Brown should do a better job maintaining their properties and the size of the new building is concerning in relation to the surrounding neighborhoods. However, they noted that the institutional master plan has changed to save 287 and 291 Brook. They acknowledged that the two houses proposed to move are certainly cost prohibitive. However, they didn’t see a benefit to issue a continuance as they expressed that Brown has met their institutional master plan amendment criteria. They noted that what was proposed by Brown is what they are already allowed to do and that in fitting within the institutional zone, the plans are legal.
A motion was then made to approve the plan with conditions, subject that Brown must work with the city engineer to implement traffic calming suggestions based on the Planning Department’s staff report. Motion was seconded and voted 3:2, with three approvals.
With this approval, Brown will be allowed to proceed, and 277 and 281-283 Brook are closer to being added to the university’s growing list of demolitions.
Smithfield: The town of Smithfield’s Town Council voted 5-0 at their October 6 meeting to designate a new local historic district called the Esmond Historic District. The district includes two town-owned buildings comprised of the East Smithfield Neighborhood Center and the Allenville Mill Storehouse. This designation came with an amendment to the Smithfield Code of Ordinances and is now Smithfield’s first local historic district. With this designation, the site allows Smithfield to have Certified Local Government (CLG) status which will make the town eligible for CLG grants through the Rhode Island Historical Preservation and Heritage Commission. The town will focus on a structural and conditions report for the Allenville Mill Storehouse. Preserve RI congratulates the town of Smithfield for the districts passing.
East Greenwich: The Town of East Greenwich Demolition by Neglect Ordinance was passed and adopted by the Town Council at its third reading on November 9. Over the past two readings, (September 28 and October 26), the Council discussed the process of addressing historically or architecturally significant structures allowed to deteriorate. It would begin with Historic District Commission review, then move to the Council, followed by notice and a full Council hearing. If neglect is established, and the owner fails to act, the town may undertake necessary preservation work and place a lien on the property for the cost of the work.
Feedback from the public expressed concerns about property owners with financial hardships. In the past, owners would face a lien at 12.5% annually on a property identified by the Historic District Commission and Council as neglected. Obviously, a lien would compound the problems for a financially challenged owner. Therefore, language was added stating that for sufficient cause, the Council could release a lien either in whole, in part, or waive any interest. Additionally, if financial hardship was deemed to be causing the neglect, the Commission and/or Council could refer an owner to the Town’s Director of Community Services. With these concerns addressed, the Council passed the ordinance 5-0.
Preserve RI congratulates the East Greenwich Town Council, Historic District Commission, Planning Commission, Planning Department and everyone involved for their work on this significant ordinance.



